Support Us Button Widget

KC sandwich recommendations: ours and yours

Table of Contents

We love a sandwich. Everybody loves a sandwich. We asked you about the sandwiches in KC that you love, and you answered. Let’s get right into the meat of it (or, if you prefer, the plant-based substitute).

KCtoday’s picks

City Editor Travis: Mildred’s Chili-Basil Breakfast Sandwich — it’s everything I love, and it has never let me down. Add chicken if you’re feeling ambitious.

Multi-city Editor Dayten: Helen’s JAD Bar in NKC. Sticky tables. $4 Boulevards on Sunday. You’ll get the Nashville hot chicken tossed in Thai peanut & sweet chili sauce. No lettuce, tomato, or onion — just pickles.

Managing Editor Josh: The burnt ends sandwich from Arthur Bryant’s. It’s just the perfect sandwich. Burnt ends: amazing. Bread: amazing. Sauce: amazing. Not a vegetable in sight.

Editorial Intern Mac: I like the Italian Club Panini from Cupini’s!

Sales Executive Amanda: I would say… Browne’s Reuben or the Baltimore Club [from Milwaukee Delicatessen].

Because if you want a traditional reuben, why not visit the oldest Irish business outside of Ireland?

Reader favorites

Cindy H.: “Breakfast sandwich at the Happy Gillis!”

Autumn + Robert T.: “The Rooben from Kind Food. My dad used to make homemade reubens growing up, and Kind Food’s version brings me back to childhood and hits ALL the right tastebud notes.”

Nostalgia is our favorite flavor — right up there with sweet and salty.

Margo S.: “Smoketown BBQ signature sandwich is the best!”

Paul W.: “The ‘Hook ‘Em Up’ at the M & M Bakery and Delicatessen at 1721 E. 31st St. in KCMO. [...] It’s huge, messy and delicious!”

Paul would also like to remind everyone that no deli visit is complete without a cookie. An M & M cookie, not an M&M cookie.

Linda R.: “The Bánh Mì sandwich at Pigwich in the City Market! Sit outside on a picnic table on a Saturday […] perfect summer picnic!”

And summer’s running out, so hop to it.

More from KCtoday
Here’s the deal — the swap meet and vintage shopping scene is stellar in the KC metro.
Raking in the leaves? Here’s how to bag, bundle, and bin them the KCMO-approved way this fall and spring.
Dining in Kansas City is always a fresh experience with new restaurants popping up all the time — and more on the way.
Structures deemed significant have special protections + rules regarding exterior renovations, upkeep, and demolition. Check if your home falls under this designation, along with tools to research its history.
Whether you’re looking to pick your own or pick it up from the country store, we’ve got 9 of the metro’s best spots for seasonal fun.
The Bam Bam Room is ready to welcome beginners and seasoned players for daily games and boutique finds.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
We’ve got a game for you — test your knowledge of how well you know Kansas City venues by the address alone.
There’s a lot to look forward to in Kansas City over the next few years. See what other locals are most excited for and when to expect construction to wrap up.
Atlas9 plans to attract locals and tourists alike for an otherworldly journey through its 48,000 sqft of themed rooms and corridors.