Support Us Button Widget

Kansas City restaurants you miss the most

KCtoday readers shared which local restaurants + meals spark deep nostalgia — and we think you’ll agree.

KCtoday_Defunct Restaurants GIF

Some have moved, others are gone forever. | Photos via Kansas City Public Library

Earlier this month, we asked: Which Kansas City restaurant do you miss the most? Which restaurant or meal do you wish were still around?

Piece of cake, right? KCtoday readers sent us food for thought — let’s stroll down memory lane, because we love a moment of local nostalgia.

Houston’s

Over its 30-year tenure, the national chain ingratiated itself into hometown staple-status thanks to its quality American grill fare (and those unforgettable chicken strips). Its long-time Plaza location closed in 2017 due to lease disagreements, but new ownership may mean a second chance.

Reader Christie G. laments the prime rib sandwich that got her through three pregnancies, while Connie M. can still taste its sunbelt salad and skinny fries.

Stephenson’s Old Apple Farm Restaurant

The Independence orchard serving apple fritters and fresh cider by the barrel will soon live on atop grocery store shelves. Reader S. W. misses its country chic decor, mouthwatering brisket, and homemade peach margaritas "....what more is there to say except, Stephenson’s, I hope I find you in heaven.”

The Wishbone

It’s where the name brand salad dressing got its start, and where reader Mary Jo M. shared countless birthday dinners over “the lightest, sweetest vanilla white cake with incredible piped frosting [...] topped with a sparkler.”

Peppercorn Duck Club

The Hyatt Regency Crown Center establishment offered a classic fine dining experience that was best known for its... you guessed it... duck. For readers Karen F. and Cindy M., its chocolate dessert bar can never be beat. “The smell of the Garlic Bread being fried throughout the restaurant will always be a favorite memory,” said John B.

Antoine’s on the Boulevard

Reader Casey C. touted the “booze soaked watermelon loaded fruit and tonka trucks full of shrimp,” but what made the Italian eatery special seems to have been its unique touches: a ring pop for every kid, a flower for every lady, and “a sucker for every guy paying the bill,” according to Keith A.

Beignet

“Standing in line on a Saturday morning in the River Market was absolutely worth it to devour a Mr. Crab stuffed beignet with a side of Cajun aioli,” recalls reader Beth O. — and we couldn’t agree more.

Y’all understood the assignment.

More from KCtoday
Kansas City nearly became the capital of animation when Disney began his career here in 1921, and a local nonprofit is working to revive that legacy to usher in a new era of creativity in the metro.
Escape the cold in KC by taking one of these affordable flights to a new city.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
Depending on your furry, feathered, or scaled friend of choice, there are a few rules for local pet owners to keep in mind.
We’ve rounded up local deals that’ll help you enjoy your lunch break without breaking the bank.
Sponsored
Check out the tees and hoodies perfect for cheering on the Chiefs as they go for a “three-peat” this Super Bowl.
Real fans don’t wait to get their Chiefs gear.
See what awards local chefs, restaurants + bars may walk away with at this year’s “Food Oscars.”
If you don’t have coffee already in hand, consider this your sign to grab some one of these 30+ locally-owned spots in and around Kansas City.